NYC Getting Meatier: Gotham Burger Opening in UWS


UPDATE: Opening JUNE 5th

WIN: One of 2 $50 Gift Certificates to use at Gotham Burger

The relatively new but successful Teaneck eatery, Gotham Burger, is opening a 2nd location in Manhattan’s Upper West Side neighborhood, only blocks from the new Amsterdam Burger Co. (owned by the same owners as Mike’s Bistro).

According to Great Kosher Restaurants:

They are turning the place into a sports bar/burger place with a VIP lounge. The owners promise that they will be offering the same great food that they are known for with a NYC edge (think beer in hand watching a large screen TV).  Pre-paid Friday night Shabbos meals will be available once they are up and running.

Gotham Burger replaced Burgers Bar last year in Teaneck, NJ. Burgers Bar, the Israeli burger chain which had locations in Brooklyn, Cedarhurst, and Teaneck, have all closed.

The new burger joint will be opening in the former “Meat Me” located at 726 Amsterdam Ave, between W 95th & 96th streets.

View Gotham Burger Co in a larger map

About the author

Dani Klein

Dani Klein is the founder of YeahThatsKosher, is passionate about global travel, good kosher food / restaurants, social media & the web, technology, digital marketing, and spending time with his friends & family.

Dani has an MBA in Marketing and works in the Social Media Marketing field for a large media agency.

  • Sounds great! I still haven’t made it to the Teaneck location, but looking forward to trying one of the spots.

  • mm, i’ll have to try it!

  • Sarah Klinkowitz

    I tell my hubby we have to try places in the city. This would be a good choice I think!

  • This is so exciting! Looks like it will be a great date place

  • It is amazing how many kosher restaurants have opened on the UWS since I lived there. I wish I was still there to try this new restaurant!

  • Whit @ jewhungry.wordpress.com

    I saw your Instagram pics from this place over the weekend and yum!! (It also helps that my hubby and I watched a Batman marathon this weekend).

    • This place isn’t open yet, so my Instagram pics must’ve been from somewhere else.

      • Whit @ jewhungry.wordpress.com

        Hmmm, my mistake. Saw burgers. Thought it was. Regardless, meat. yum.

  • Alison Barnett

    Awesome! Something the city does not have yet that’s kosher!

  • I think it stinks that this restaurant is opening 3 blocks from Amsterdam Burger Co. We finally have an excellent (and organic) kosher burger place on the uws and now there are going to be 2 places competing for business.
    In the end we could very well end up with no kosher burgers places on the uws.

  • Pingback: High-End Burgers Flood New York Kosher Restaurants | Kosher & Jewish Travel Guide | Kosher Restaurants | Kosher Forum • YeahThatsKosher.com()

  • עמרם

    I’ve see some negative reviews on Yelp on Gotham Burger in Teaneck NJ. What do you have on it?


Facebook Group

Credit Card Offers

  • SQUARE – $1k in Free Credit Card Processing

Up to 80k UR points | Apply

Up to 25k points
Apply (Personal Card) | Apply (Biz Card)

Up to $150 Cash Back + 6% Back on Groceries | Apply

Up to 80k points | Apply

Up to 15k Points + No fee!| Read more | Apply