After 16 years of serving the Midwood community, Benny’s Pizza on Avenue J has permanently closed after losing its lease. The restaurant was a reliable destination for kosher pizza lovers, with many customers reminiscing about its classic cheese slices, hearty pasta dishes, and friendly atmosphere. Benny’s had become a staple for locals, yeshiva students, and anyone walking the bustling Avenue J strip.
While this location is now shuttered, the original Benny’s on Avenue M remains open, continuing to serve the community with its signature offerings. The closure leaves a noticeable gap in the Avenue J kosher dining scene, though there are still several strong pizza options nearby.
Kosher Pizza Options Still Thriving on Avenue J
Despite the loss of Benny’s, kosher pizza lovers on Avenue J still have reliable choices to satisfy their cravings:
Perizia Kosher Pizza
Located at 3003 Avenue J, Perizia is known for its extensive menu of specialty pizzas, including Grandma slices, penne vodka pies, and even gluten-free crust options. The shop is popular for both its variety and freshness, and it maintains regular hours during the week and after Shabbat.
Pizza Time
A few blocks down at 1324 Avenue J, Pizza Time offers a classic Brooklyn pizzeria vibe with thin-crust pies, baked pasta dishes, and salad options. It’s a popular choice for casual takeout or quick sit-down meals.
Avenue J Remains a Hub for Kosher Pizza
Although the closure of Benny’s Pizza marks the end of a chapter on Avenue J, kosher dining continues to thrive in Midwood. With longstanding pizzerias like Perizia and Pizza Time offering unique takes on kosher pizza, locals still have plenty of flavorful options to enjoy.
Benny’s Pizza on Avenue J was located at 1418 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY. It was kosher certified and operated for over a decade before closing in April 2025.
Other Benny’s Pizza Locations
Benny’s Pizza remains open on Avenue M in Brooklyn at 1802 Ave M.
Benny’s Pizza in Queens is not a related business to the closed location in Brooklyn.
