Double-booking restaurant reservations may appear to be a minor, harmless act to some travelers.
However, this behavior can have major consequences for restaurants, fellow travelers, and the broader Jewish community. The issue has drawn particular attention recently at Cinko restaurant at Baha Mar in the Bahamas, and in previous years at numerous restaurants in South Florida, prompting our friend, Elan Kornblum of Great Kosher Restaurants, to call this out about the negative impact of reservation abuse on Facebook.
During high-demand travel periods—such as winter vacations or Jewish holidays—kosher restaurants are in especially high demand, and double-bookings become more than just a nuisance. They can lead to real financial, logistical, and even moral ramifications.
In this article, we’ll examine why double-booking is unethical, the harm it causes, and the steps that restaurants and businesses can take to prevent such behavior—namely, more robust reservation policies and mandatory deposits. We’ll also explore how double-booking touches on the idea of Chilul Hashem, which should be a significant concern in the Orthodox Jewish community.
1. Understanding the Problem
Many travelers book multiple reservations at different restaurants in case their plans change or to simply “keep options open.” (Understanding that this is far from the majority but significantly enough that it’s become at issue in multiple places over a few years). Sometimes, they might be uncertain about timing with a large group or traveling with children who have unpredictable schedules. Sometimes these are forward thinking travelers, booking reservations months in advance. However, when these customers fail to cancel unwanted reservations, restaurants end up with empty tables and wasted resources.
In a destination like Baha Mar or Miami, where kosher establishments cater to an influx of Jewish kosher-observant tourists, particularly during peak times like Yeshiva Week, the problem is magnified.
The restaurant prepares for full capacity—sourcing ingredients, scheduling additional staff, and estimating exact portions to maintain kosher standards. No-shows or late cancellations leave these businesses with extra staff who may be underutilized, unsold perishable ingredients, and lost revenue. As Elan highlighted, the financial and logistical burden can be overwhelming for kosher establishments that already face higher operational costs than non-kosher counterparts.
2. Impact on Restaurants
a. Financial Strain
Double-booking directly hurts restaurants’ bottom lines. Kosher restaurants often invest heavily in ingredients, certification costs, and specialized staff to comply with kashrut laws. When no-shows occur, revenue is lost for that time slot—even more so if there are no walk-in customers to occupy the empty seats. The restaurant’s investments for the evening essentially go to waste, and these losses can accumulate quickly.
b. Food Waste
Because kosher establishments must adhere to strict sourcing and preparation guidelines, many buy only what they can realistically use to avoid waste. However, expecting a full house can push them to stock more than usual. If multiple parties fail to show, perishable items may be discarded, compounding financial losses and generating needless waste.
c. Staff Burnout
Peak travel seasons require restaurants to bring in additional staff to manage high volumes. When seats remain empty because of no-shows, staff members lose potential tips and face frustration over wasted effort. This can lead to low morale and higher turnover—two significant concerns in the hospitality industry, particularly in niche kosher markets.
3. Impact on Other Travelers & Diners
a. Limited Capacity
During busy travel seasons, kosher restaurants are often scarce in certain vacation hotspots, especially at the most in demand restaurants. When someone double-books and fails to use a reservation, it prevents other hungry travelers from enjoying that table—leading to longer wait times or being turned away altogether.
b. Worsening Wait Times
The host or hostess might be forced to juggle tables based on reservations that could remain unclaimed. This uncertainty clogs the seating process, lengthens wait times, and causes confusion. Even guests who arrive promptly may find themselves waiting while staff tries to verify whether a party will actually show up.
4. A Matter of Chilul Hashem
For the frum community, ethical behavior should extend beyond mere compliance with secular law or social norms. Chilul Hashem, literally a “desecration of God’s name,” occurs when Jews act in a way that brings shame or dishonor to Judaism and, by extension, to God’s reputation in the eyes of the world. When members of the community engage in harmful practices, even seemingly small acts like double-booking reservations—where restaurants are left to bear the financial, logistical, and emotional burdens—it can be seen as a Chilul Hashem.
1. Reflecting on Our Actions: By contributing to wasted resources and fostering ill will, double-booking can cause onlookers—Jewish or not—to question the ethical standards of those who practice it. This reflects poorly not only on the individuals but potentially on the broader Jewish community.
2. Responsibility Toward Others: Halacha places a strong emphasis on being considerate of other people’s livelihoods. When you reserve a table, you enter into a small but meaningful partnership (even an informal contract) with the restaurant. Neglecting to fulfill that commitment can be construed as failing in the moral responsibility that members of a community owe to each other.
3. Preserving a Good Name: Kosher restaurants in tourist hotspots serve as public institutions to the Jewish community. When they suffer due to irresponsible behavior, that suffering reverberates. Fostering positive relationships—upholding commitments, respecting others’ livelihoods—aligns with the Torah’s commandments about honest, ethical dealings. Conversely, ignoring those values can result in a Chilul Hashem.
According to Rabbi Reuben Ibragimov of Chazak at the Edmond J. Synagogue in New York, NY: “I believe booking 2 restaurants for the same time falls into the category of Geneivat Da’at “stealing someone’s mind”—deceptively creating a false impression that misleads another person. When you double book a restaurant reservation without intending to honor one of the bookings, you risk misleading the establishment into believing you genuinely plan to dine there. This could result in the restaurant holding a table for you unnecessarily, potentially denying other families the opportunity to dine at that restaurant and even causing financial loss as they withhold that table from someone else.”
5. Preventing Bad Behavior: Steps for Restaurants and Businesses
Given the severity of the problem—both financially and morally—restaurants can adopt strategies to minimize no-shows and encourage responsible reservation habits:
a. Mandatory Deposits
One of the strongest deterrents is requiring a deposit or per-person hold when booking reservations during peak seasons or for large parties. This deposit should be substantial enough to discourage casual multiple bookings. If someone fails to show up without canceling in time, the restaurant recovers at least a portion of the anticipated revenue.
I believe that this is a good and fair step for restaurants to take during peak seasons, like Yeshiva Week / Winter Break, Pesach, and other holiday periods.
b. Credit Card Holds and Clear Cancellation Policies
A transparent cancellation policy is key. Restaurants that request a credit card number and specify a cancellation deadline force patrons to think carefully about overbooking. If guests ignore the policy, they face a cancellation fee. Publicizing this policy through a reservation platform, website, or social media helps avoid misunderstandings and sets clear expectations.
c. Waitlist Management and Communication
A robust reservation system that includes waitlists allows restaurants to fill empty seats quickly when a party cancels last-minute or simply doesn’t show. Automated email or text reminders sent to customers a day or two beforehand can prompt them to confirm or cancel their reservations in time to free the table for someone else.
Conclusion
Double-booking restaurant reservations during busy travel seasons—particularly in places with limited kosher options, such as Baha Mar in the Bahamas—may appear trivial, but the damage inflicted on restaurants, fellow diners, and the broader community is real. These practices undermine businesses that invest heavily to serve a niche but important market. Beyond the financial and logistical consequences, double-booking can also lead to a Chilul Hashem, damaging the moral fabric and reputation of the Jewish community.
However, by instituting stronger reservation policies—like mandatory deposits, credit card holds, clear cancellation windows, and effective waitlist systems—restaurants can mitigate no-shows. Just as importantly, open communication and community education can remind travelers of their ethical and religious obligations. In doing so, kosher businesses can continue to flourish, and travelers can preserve the sense of unity and integrity that is so integral to the Jewish travel experience. When both sides work together, the outcome is a win-win: thriving restaurants, satisfied diners, and a community that practices responsible behavior—one reservation at a time.
This is not a post I took pleasure in writing, but I do feel the responsibility to call out bad behavior in our community where it exists, and where it’s related to what we talk about here. BH, this won’t be an issue in the future.
Add Comment